• AES_Enjoyer@reddthat.com
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    22 hours ago

    Any source from anywhere could be propaganda

    Which is why I’m bringing up things such as the overwhelming lack of photographic evidence over the 5+ years since the claims started, not exclusively blaming the BBC.

    Here is your chance to debunk the BBC report if you want

    Very convenient how the burden of proof is on me to prove that a report is fake. Casting away fake news is easy and doesn’t require any research or effort, debunking them is more complicated. How about this: the lack of photographic evidence from the BBC or any other report is enough for me to deny the claims of genocide.

    You are confusing banning news production by foreigners with banning transmission of foreign news

    No, I talked about both, I gave you the explicit example of the lack of Chinese state media in US institutional press releases.

    China probably forbids BBC news with their great internet firewall

    Good. Things like this are why there isn’t a pro-fascist movement in China, unlike the western world. China is progressively opening up now that it has enough soft power to maintain the western propaganda at bay, whereas the west closes up to Chinese social media by banning Tiktok or requiring it to have american ownership.

    know they ban the Tiananmen Square massacre imagery

    Yet you can readily find pictures of it happening, how come you can’t find pictures of a 5-year-long genocide in the age of smartphones?

    Not “every single Uygur”, just the ones locked up

    The reeducation centers are almost all closed already. I’m not arguing there wasn’t a reeducation campaign for a few years in Xinjiang targeting Uyghur people as a measure of counter-terrorism, I’m arguing that it’s already over (hence no news since 2022-2023) and that it doesn’t remotely constitute genocide.

    • sqgl@sh.itjust.works
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      5 hours ago

      Seems you missed my point:

      Again: how does China stop every single Uyghur adult from taking pics with their smartphone?

      Not “every single Uygur”, just the ones locked up. That is how detention works, even in the West.

      So there was the BBS and the PBS report another person provided in the comments.

      By the way, I agree there was no genocide. See my other comments where I acknowledge the Uighur separatist movement threatening access to the Sil Road so obviously the CCP has to try something.