Previous Thread | Next Thread

Another week is upon us, which means another weekly thread. For those of you out there that prescribe to the three episode rule of thumb for shows, it is crunch time for shows to prove their worth. As always, please use this thread however you like, whether that be questions, comments, suggestions, etc. Some examples might be:

  • Who did it better, Frieren’s First Class Mage Exam or Harry Potter’s Tri-Wizard Tournament?
  • Is The Dangers in My Heart a cautionary tale about high cholesterol?
  • In Blue Exorcist, why doesn’t somebody cheer him up?

As always, remember to be mindful of spoilers. If you want to know more about how to handle spoilers in this community, check the guide here (also linked in the sidebar).

  • e0qdk@kbin.social
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    10 months ago

    I had somewhat limited time this past week, but wanted to keep working through my backlog of unfinished shows, so I pulled up the short (6 episode) series Looking Up At The Half-Moon and watched that. I think I dropped this after episode 2 the first time I tried it, but finished it this time.

    The show is a hospital drama + romance, which seems unusual for anime. I don’t think I’ve watched any other anime set almost entirely in a hospital before – scenes, yes, but not the whole show. I’m not generally into medical drama so I haven’t really gone looking though; this is one I went into blind originally.

    Guess which novel shows up again! Yup, it’s Night on the Galactic Railroad. I feel like I’m seeing this book everywhere now, and this show quotes from it directly; one of the characters has pretty much memorized it. Something I noticed from the quotes is that one of the characters (in the novel) is named Campanella – which should ring bells for anyone who’s played the Trails series… No idea if there’s actually a connection there, but I thought it was interesting.

    The show strained my suspension of disbelief with how a number of characters acted, but did some things I found interesting as well. The doctor’s characterization did not go in quite the direction I expected, and there were a number of other surprises throughout. Episode 5 in particularly really went somewhere I wasn’t expecting. I kind of feel like I should write more about that… but it would all be spoilers.

    • wjs018@ani.socialOPM
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      10 months ago

      You bring up a good point I hadn’t really thought about before, that the medical drama genre isn’t as represented in anime as it is in Western media. There are many examples that I can think of from US television (House, ER, Grey’s Anatomy, etc.), and I haven’t even watched any of those shows. However, I would really have to go searching to try to find them in anime form. Maybe games? I can think of the Trauma Center series of games which are medical drama visual novels. Interesting observation!

      In any case, I tend not to watch medical shows because it is a bit too close to what I do professionally, and my suspension of disbelief is pretty easily stretched beyond the breaking point when it is in a field I actually know a lot about. It really makes me think that other genres must also really stretch reality quite a bit, but I just don’t know enough to know any better. Next thing I know, you are going to tell me that soccer isn’t played like it is in Blue Lock.